Text Size
Print
Email
Top Stories
- Text Size
- Print
- Email
CRA's Responsibilities Reporting Criminal Records
What more should a Credit Reporting Agency (CRA) do for criminal record checks other than using a trusted source and reporting their findings?
That's a critical area where CRAs handling criminal record checks need to go beyond simply accessing and reporting information from trusted sources. Given the significant impact criminal records can have on individuals' lives (employment, housing, etc.), CRAs have a responsibility to ensure accuracy, fairness, and compliance.
Here's what more they should be doing:
Ensuring Accuracy and Context Beyond the Initial Record:
Verification and Validation: While using trusted sources is key, CRAs should implement additional layers of verification to ensure the record pertains to the specific individual. This could involve cross-referencing with multiple identifiers (beyond name and date of birth), and in some cases, even manual review for common names.
Considering the Disposition of the Case: It's crucial to report the full disposition of a case, not just an arrest record. This includes whether charges were dropped, the individual was acquitted, or the outcome of any conviction. Reporting only an arrest can be misleading and unfairly stigmatizing.
Accounting for Expungements and Sealed Records: CRAs must have robust processes in place to identify and properly handle expunged or sealed records, ensuring they are not reported in violation of legal requirements. This requires staying up-to-date with varying state laws and implementing effective data management practices.
Providing Contextual Information (Where Legally Permissible and Ethical): While they shouldn't editorialize, providing legally permissible context, such as the level of the offense (misdemeanor vs. felony) and the date of the offense, can help the user of the report better understand the information.
Regular Audits of Data Sources: CRAs should regularly audit their data sources to ensure their accuracy, reliability, and adherence to legal standards.
Promoting Fairness and Compliance:
Adhering to the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) and State Laws: Strict adherence to the FCRA and relevant state laws regarding the use and reporting of criminal records is paramount. This includes providing proper disclosures to consumers and following specific procedures for adverse action based on criminal record information.
Establishing Clear Guidelines for Users of Criminal Record Information: CRAs should provide clear guidelines to their clients (e.g., employers, landlords) on the legal and ethical considerations when using criminal record information for decision-making. This could include information on Ban the Box laws and individualized assessment requirements.
Offering Resources and Information to Consumers: CRAs should provide clear and accessible information to consumers about their rights regarding criminal background checks, including how to dispute inaccuracies and understand the impact of their records.
Training Staff on Fair and Accurate Reporting: Ensuring that CRA staff involved in processing and reporting criminal record information are thoroughly trained on legal requirements, accuracy standards, and ethical considerations is essential.
Regular Legal Review: CRAs should regularly consult with legal experts to ensure their practices remain compliant with evolving laws and regulations related to criminal record reporting.
Improving the Consumer Experience:
Transparent Dispute Processes: Consumers should have a clear and easy process for disputing inaccuracies in their criminal record information, with timely and thorough investigations by the CRA.
Clear Communication: CRAs should communicate clearly with consumers about the status and outcome of their disputes.
Easy Access to Reports: Consumers should have easy and affordable access to their own criminal background reports to review for accuracy.
Considering Ethical Implications:
Advocating for Fair Chance Practices: While their primary role is reporting, CRAs could potentially advocate for or educate on fair chance practices and the responsible use of criminal background checks.
Staying Informed on the Societal Impact: CRAs should be aware of the broader societal impact of criminal record reporting and strive to balance the needs of their clients with the rights and rehabilitation of individuals with past convictions.
In conclusion, simply reporting information from a trusted source is insufficient for CRAs handling criminal records. They must actively work to ensure the accuracy and completeness of the information, adhere strictly to legal requirements, promote fairness in its use, and provide robust support and transparency for consumers. This requires a more proactive and responsible approach than with traditional credit data due to the sensitive nature and potential impact of criminal history information.
2025 The Background Investigator. All Rights Reserved.